10 Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin: Reviews & Guide 2021

Kaileigh Clemons
Written by
Last update:

Men’s skin is different from women’s. Men have coarser, harder skin and most importantly, most men have sensitive skin. That’s why a lot of shaving creams designed for women simply aren’t strong enough for men.

Wouldn’t they work fine?

Yes sometimes they do, but not often.

Many men end up buying or using women’s shaving creams which are cheaper, however, they don’t work well for men and can be stripping if you’re truly looking for a product for sensitive skin.

So, if you’re looking for the best shaving cream for men with sensitive skin in 2019, you have come to the right place. We’ve done all the research and testing for you and below you will find the cream we found to be the best for men in 2019.

NameCategoryProduct
Edge Shave GelBest OverallEdge Shave Gel
Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shave CreamBudget PickPacific Shaving Company Natural Shave Cream
Aveeno Positively Smooth Moisturizing Shave GelUpgrade PickAveeno Positively Smooth Moisturizing Shave Gel

1. Edge Shave Gel

Our rating: 9 / 10

Edge Shave Gel

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Good for sensitive skin
  • Long lasting fresh smell
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Overly drying ingredients
  • May cause skin irritation

Edge Shave Gel Sensitive Skin is one of the best creams for men with sensitive skin.

That said, it’s ironic that the Edge Shave Gel for sensitive skin is so hard on the sensitive skin of men, according to customer reviews. But it’s cheap!

According to many sensitive skin men who’ve tried Edge, you get what you pay for. Though it’s available at a great price, Edge 7-Ounce Sensitive Skin Go Fresh Scent Shave Gel can cause skin irritation, burning, redness, and itching.

2. Cremo Barber Grade Cooling Shave Cream

Our rating: 9 / 10

Cremo Barber Grade Cooling Shave Cream

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Soothes skin
  • Provides a smooth, close shave
  • Has superior hydration for the skin
  • Contains a witch hazel to prevent inflammation and razor burn
  • Has a light citrus scent

Cons:

  • Very small packaging
  • Has a thick consistency that can be hard to get out of the tube

Cremo is a world class shaving brand from California. It is renowned for its practical, stylish, easy to use, and effective products. The Cremo Barber Cooling Shave Cream is no exception. It comes in a 6Z tube, and it has an SPF 15 (protecting your face from sun damage).

After applying this shaving cream on your face, it will leave your face feeling fresh, smooth, and toned. Also, there is a very light smell of citrus, which not many people will like.

When it comes to shaving, sometimes the razor never gets the close shave that the user wants, but this razor has the power to make that razor a lot closer. Also, the razor blades last longer because of the shave that this cream provides.

3. NIVEA Men Sensitive Shaving Foam

Our rating: 9 / 10

NIVEA Men Sensitive Shaving Foam

Check Price on Amazon

Not only does it provide an invigorating shaving experience, but it is a very cost effective option. The Nivea Men Sensitive Shaving Foam can be kept in your bathroom, bathroom cabinet, or your shaving drawer. Easy to buy, easy to find.

The canister size is 7 oz. and comes in a pack of 6. For the most part, a 6 pack can last most guys about 3 months or that is how long you’ll wait until you need to replenish your stock.

This shaving foam is suitable for sensitive skin and will not leave your face irritated with redness or severe burns.

4. Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shave Cream

Our rating: 9 / 10

Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shave Cream

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Vegan, Biodegradable, Gluten-Free, Non-Toxic, No Synthetic Fragrances or Dyes, Paraben-Free, Cruelty-Free.
  • Pacific Shaving Company offers a wide variety of shaving products like Coconut Lime Shaving Soap, Coconut and Lime Shaving Cream, Coconut Lime Aftershave, Coconut Lime Shave Oil, Coconut Lime Shave Soap, Ginger Lime Shaving Cream, Ginger Lime Aftershave, Ginger Lime Shave Oil, and Ginger Lime Shave Soap. All of their scents are 100% natural.
  • The creamy lather created by Pacific Shaving Company's natural shave creams leaves your skin feeling soft and smooth. Pacific Shaving Company's natural shaving creams are fragrance-free and work extremely well whether you exclusively use a razor or opt for a straight-edge.
  • Available in Coconut Lime, Tea Tree, Sweet Orange, Unscented, Cinnamon, and Pomegranate.
  • Shaving Creams are suitable for all skin types, and are even gentle enough for sensitive skin. All of Pacific Shaving Company's shave creams are paraben-free, nutritive, and enriched with natural ingredients.
  • Pacific Shaving Company's shaving creams are cruelty-free and made in the USA.

Cons:

  • There are less scents to choose from.

5. Taylor of Old Bond Street Jermyn Street Luxury Shaving Cream

Our rating: 8 / 10

Taylor of Old Bond Street Jermyn Street Luxury Shaving Cream

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • * It can be used on all skin types including sensitive * Very smooth and comfortable under the razor * A nice creamy lather * Leaves your skin smooth and moisturized * Mild enough scent * Affordable price Cons: * Soap like color can turn fingers yellow * Large tub

This one is a good option for those of you trying to find a suitable shaving cream for sensitive skin. It’s extra soothing and hydrating and made with natural ingredients like glycerin, rosemary, and sweet almond. No parabens, no alcohols, no dyes, no SLS, and safe for those with allergies. What’s more, it’s never tested on animals!

It smells amazing and takes you back in time. The soap-like smell of the shaving cream will impress you. The jar is pretty big and it’s in a nice plastic box, which is a nice touch. The cream smells very nice and it isn’t overpowering. Users have been raving about that amazing smell and that it reminds them of their grandfathers.

6. Aveeno Positively Smooth Moisturizing Shave Gel

Our rating: 8 / 10

Aveeno Positively Smooth Moisturizing Shave Gel

Check Price on Amazon

Aveeno is a trusted name in personal care products. In fact, it was the first cosmetics company to incorporate natural ingredients into its product line, with it's active ingredient oatmeal as an example. Aveeno Shave Gel contains skin conditioners that leave the skin healthy, smooth and great smelling.

Many of the ingredients used are derived for natural sources, such as soy and aloe. It contains vitamin E, essential oil blend and feather-light conditioning agents.

It helps soften hair and gently protects it from bumps and cuts. This gel uses a fragrance free, it is paraben free and it's a great choice for those with sensitive skin.

7. Shaving Cream

Our rating: 8 / 10

Shaving Cream

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • No bad smells
  • Very hydrating
  • Lightweight
  • No irritants
  • Travel-friendly

Cons:

  • Does not work well with sensitive skin
  • Dries out hands
  • Dries out skin

This shaving cream for men has no frills, no added chemicals, and no bad smells.

The Rocky Mountain Barber Company Shave Soap, formulated from the finest ingredients, creates a nice thick lather, ideal for shaving.

It is ideal for sensitive skin and even sensitive noses. It features a proprietary sandalwood essential oil blend that both cleanses and hydrate skin. The issue with this particular product is that it causes skin dryness and irritation for a lot of users.

8. Proraso Shaving Cream

Our rating: 8 / 10

Proraso Shaving Cream

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Long lasting supply
  • No artificial colors or scents, best for sensitive skin
  • Ideal for both sensitive skin and for daily use

Cons:

  • The tube isn’t very sturdy & tends to crack in some areas
  • The company only uses alcohol-free ingredients

Proraso, brought to the US by Bruce Everiss, is one of the most popular brands of shaving cream and is known for being fairly simple, yet highly effective. The ideal cream for those with sensitive skin and for daily use.

The Proraso shaving cream is perfect for beginners thanks to its simplicity. It’s made with just 5 natural ingredients, (notably also without a single artificial color or scent), and that’s why it’s ideal for sensitive skin. This creamy, bubbly lather is ideal for applying to your face and helps to foam up a great lather.

The tube is slightly smaller than what you’d see in a typical can of shaving cream. It’s about the size of a small stick of deodorant, but it still lasts for a long time, especially considering that a little bit goes a long way.

9. Neutrogena Men Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

Our rating: 8 / 10

Neutrogena Men Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Works well for dry and sensitive skin
  • Affordable
  • Neutrogena is a trusted name in shaving care
  • Natural ingredients

If you are in search for an all natural, affordable, products, then aim for this shaving cream from Neutrogena. This cream has mild & friendly natural ingredients that help fight off skin irritation. It is a water-based cream that has a gel-like consistency. It makes sure that the skin does not get hydrated as well as the razor does not get clogged.

The cream is whipped with tiny air bubbles that help to condition the skin. It comes out white in color and applies very smoothly. It helps to create a refreshing feeling for the skin. It has a nice aroma to it, but may not be suitable for users with sensitive noses. Every man can use this cream as it is suitable for all skin types.

Who Is It For?

10. Avalon Organics Moisturizing Shave Cream

Our rating: 5 / 10

Avalon Organics Moisturizing Shave Cream

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Great for sensitive skin
  • Long-lasting results
  • Helped soothe my skin during and after use
  • Cliche packaging

Cons:

  • Tub packaging which is far less sanitary than pump packaging
  • More expensive than other products

The Avalon Organics Moisturizing Shave Cream has a great smell and my partner enjoyed using it on his face. It was an extremely thick lather which made it great for lubrication. I’ve always been wary about shaving because of the risk of getting razor burn but this product eliminated them.

The cream is a little hard to work with if you’ve never used it before. It’s very thick compared to other shaving creams. I had to use a lot to get a full application on my legs.

The packaging is quite frustrating. The lid is extremely hard to close. If you leave the lid a little open and put it in your shower it will spill all over the place! That said, none of the ingredients are toxic, which is a plus. It’s a little hard to rinse.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Which is the best shaving cream for sensitive skin?

When the subject of sensitive skin comes up, it is most likely due to the skin being red and irritated. With sensitive skin, damage and irritation can be triggered by almost anything.

Razors can also be one of the culprits of irritation. With a poor razor, even using it can cause irritation. On the other hand, with a proper razor and a quality shaving cream for sensitive skin, shaving really can be a pleasant experience.

The best shaving cream for sensitive skin will typically have a ingredient line-up like that of the Anthony Logistics Shave Cream, which contains aloe and glycolic acid. This cream will leave the skin feeling smooth, while preventing irritation and razor burn. This cream is also safe to use with both a traditional or an electric razor.

What is the best shave cream?

As men, we all know how painful it is to nicks and scars from shaving your facial hair. Some of us may only experience occasional aches and pains, and others may struggle each time they take a razor to their face.

If you’re like me and have sensitive skin, there are common ingredients found in most shave creams. These ingredients make the skin more susceptible to coming into contact with the blade. As a result, you end up with a burning, itchy rash around the hair line and those uneven, sensitive spots on your face that gunk up your razor (that you end up shaving over again because your whiskers are growing in just beneath the skin).

Ingredients are generally going to be one of three types:

  • Water
  • Fragrance
  • Coconut oil

What is the best way to shave for sensitive skin?

If you are a man with sensitive skin, you know how difficult it can be to find a good shaving cream. Traditional shave creams can dry out your skin, leading to irritation and redness. The best shaving cream for sensitive skin should have moisturizing properties and a rich, thick texture.

There are lots of good shaving creams on the market, but some are better than others. This article will provide an in-depth guide to the best shaving creams for sensitive skin. We will take a look at each of the shaving creams on our list and explain the benefits and drawbacks of each. By the time you are finished reading this article, you will be an expert at picking the right shaving cream for your sensitive skin.

What is better shave cream or gel?

Shave cream and gels are products typically used to reduce irritation on one’s skin. Though used in the same context, gels usually have the added benefit of being cooling, aiding the individual in the application process.

Shaving cream will usually be much thicker and comes with other benefits. Additionally, not every shave cream is completely free from chemicals and should be used with proper care.

Gels are also typically low-lathering and in many respects, much like a conditioner. The gel can sometimes form an oily residue when used, but this is easily cleaned away. Some lubricants are even compatible with razor blades, which is good news for athletes in the market for a new shaving cream or gel.

Conclusion

Shaving is a process that all men and women have to go through at some point in their lives. However, if you have sensitive skin, it can be lather and torture. We hope that by the end of this article, you will have the tools to help you purchase the right shaving cream for your specific skin type.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Edge Shave GelBest OverallEdge Shave Gel
Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shave CreamBudget PickPacific Shaving Company Natural Shave Cream
Aveeno Positively Smooth Moisturizing Shave GelUpgrade PickAveeno Positively Smooth Moisturizing Shave Gel